Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum
TAC Members Forum
If you have arrived here and not yet signed up as a member,
please register below using your real name.

Please create a Username that is your First Name and Surname eg. "Joe Bloggs"
(This will ensure quicker activation and save us the need to contact you about changing it)

Our Forum Membership uses Real Names only.
Aliases, Handles, Pseudonyms or any other types of made-up name are not allowed.
This helps to keep it an open and friendly place. Thanks!

www.rivertac.org
Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.


Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum
 
HomeHome  TAC Home PageTAC Home Page  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log in  
Navigation
Search
 
 

Display results as :
 
Rechercher Advanced Search
Latest topics
» Feargal Sharkey accuses Thames Water of sewage 'dumping'
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyFri Sep 04, 2020 4:24 pm by Ed Randall

» COVID-19 - Get Fishing Again
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySun Jun 07, 2020 1:04 pm by Julian Jones

» Eel Trap Molesey - 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyTue May 05, 2020 12:29 pm by Glyn Jones

» GAS STOVES
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Apr 15, 2020 7:13 am by Keith Collett

» Man missing in Thames at Shepperton
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyTue Jan 21, 2020 3:27 pm by Ed Randall

» Semi-Tidal Draw off 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyMon Oct 28, 2019 9:55 pm by Ed Randall

» Citizen Science forum at ZSL ~ 29th October 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Sep 28, 2019 4:19 pm by Ed Randall

» Citizen Crane Forum ~ 16th and 29th October 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Sep 28, 2019 4:16 pm by Ed Randall

» Tidefest match result 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyTue Sep 10, 2019 8:50 am by Ed Randall

» Closed season retained following public consultation
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Aug 22, 2019 12:20 pm by Ed Randall

» Houseboat destroyed by fire in Hampton
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyMon Aug 12, 2019 9:30 am by Ed Randall

» Local tackle shops
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyFri Jul 05, 2019 1:16 pm by Trevor Rowe

» New Season, New Licence...
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyFri Jun 14, 2019 12:24 am by Julian Jones

» FORCE Clean-Up in Donkey Wood ~ Sun 14th April 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySun Apr 21, 2019 8:19 am by Ed Randall

» The Big one - Farnborough 23rd-24th March 2019
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySun Feb 10, 2019 11:30 am by Keith Collett

» Thames So Full Of Cocaine It’s Pranging Out London’s Eels
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyTue Jan 22, 2019 9:27 am by Trevor Rowe

» "Citizen Crane" project - sampling dates
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Jan 10, 2019 8:51 am by Ed Randall

» New Members: Real Names please
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Jan 10, 2019 8:36 am by Ed Randall

» Semi-Tidal draw-off 2018
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Oct 27, 2018 5:44 pm by Ed Randall

» Thames Water Blitz - 19th/20th October 2018
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyTue Oct 02, 2018 7:21 pm by Ed Randall

» Citizen Crane Forum ~ 26th October 2018
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 7:41 pm by Ed Randall

» Invitation to the 2018 Eel forum ~ 15th October
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 7:38 pm by Ed Randall

» Mystery of dead eels found in rivers
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 6:43 pm by Ed Randall

» Eel Trap Clean Up/ training 5th May 2018 10am
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 6:40 pm by Ed Randall

» A new address for 2017 ~ forum.rivertac.org
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptySun Aug 19, 2018 12:48 pm by Admin

» Hampton Riviera removed
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Aug 16, 2018 10:41 pm by Ed Randall

» Roads closed everywhere ~ July 29th/30th ~ bike race
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyMon Aug 06, 2018 10:14 am by John LeSurf

» *Thames Tunnel (Tideway Tunnel)*
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Jul 18, 2018 9:56 am by John LeSurf

» new hotel at hampton court means loss of fishing
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Jul 04, 2018 1:26 pm by Ed Randall

» FORCE clean-up in Donkey Wood ~ Sun 13th May 2018
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu May 17, 2018 10:16 am by JeffHowe

Angling Data View
River Levels
UK Map

Thames Tides

 

 Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers

Go down 
+2
Ed Randall
David Harvey
6 posters
AuthorMessage
David Harvey

David Harvey


Male Posts : 5381
Join date : 2010-01-21
Age : 107
Location : Surrey,

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Nov 21, 2012 5:24 pm

How good, bloody amazing news

Ever had thoughts about joing the Trust, well heres one very good reason why



Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers


Fish Legal has won an historic injunction against a multi-million pound hydropower development on the River Trent at Sawley Weir, in the process exposing major failings in the regulatory process.


The membership association Fish Legal, acting for its member the Pride of Derby Angling Association (PDAA), has won the biggest case in its 64 year history by securing an injunction to stop impending construction of a flagship hydropower scheme at Sawley Weir on the River Trent. The case was heard at a four day trial in Nottingham County Court against developers the Small Hydro Company and the Canal and River Trust (CRT - previously known as British Waterways).


Fish Legal’s expert lawyers and legal counsel fought the case on the grounds that the development would have destroyed the PDAA’s 1,200 members’ enjoyment of their prime stretch of river fishing on which they own the freehold rights. The Judge found that the developers and the CRT did not consult with the PDAA until very late in the planning process, and that they should have made much more careful enquiries about the fishing rights at the outset. Indeed it appears that the company and the waterways charity CRT turned a blind eye to those rights in an attempt to sideline those with most to lose from the scheme – anglers. The Judge recognised that they either ignored or were aware of the risks, both to the scheme and the fishing rights, but they pushed forward with their plans anyway.


If the scheme had gone ahead, the natural riverbanks would have been transformed into a 150 metre-long concrete and steel industrial facility with floodlights and alarms sounding off at intervals. Anglers were expected to access their fishing via a locked security gate into a fenced compound and to perch themselves and their equipment on a series of metal platforms suspended up to eight feet above the river. The developer’s own health and safety witness conceded in court that this would put them “at risk of death”. The Judge ruled that the club should not be forced against its will to accept the proposal at the expense of its valuable fishing rights and that the scheme should not go ahead.


The company had tried to pressurise the club to accept its plan and, in spite of the anglers’ objections, pressed ahead with seeking an Impoundment Licence for the development from the Environment Agency (EA), which was granted.


The EA’s decision to grant the licence has been roundly criticised by Fish Legal and the Angling Trust as a failure of the regulator to fulfil its statutory duty to consider and give due weight to fisheries when granting impoundment licences. In this case, its ‘consideration’ was limited to a single (unclear) sentence:“Part of Pride of Derby’s fishery lies within the weir pool affected i.e. increased periods of reduced flow during operation of the turbine”. This minimal level of attention is utterly inadequate from a public body which has a statutory duty to maintain, improve and develop fisheries (i.e. angling) and the Judge’s decision that the fishing rights would be significantly harmed demonstrates the EA’s failure in this regard.


What's more, by granting the licence, the EA handed the company a statutory defence to any claims against it for damage to the fishery caused by modifying water levels and flow rates. Fish Legal therefore had to limit its civil legal action to the narrower point of the impact on the club’s access to the fishery and the physical ability of its members to fish there, but they still won the case.


The scheme at Sawley was one of many being planned in the region by the Small Hydro Company, but there are also hundreds of others planned across the country by other private companies, often backed by private equity and major financial institutions, who are engaged in a gold rush to make profits from generating hydropower principally because of generous feed in tariffs from the taxpayer.


Even if all the 26,000 sites identified by the EA which might be suitable for hydropower were to be developed, they would still generate less than 0.5% of the nation’s electricity supply but would have a major strategic impact on fish and fishing. Low head hydropower therefore makes a negligible contribution to tackling climate change, but has a very significant impact on freshwater ecology. Taxpayers’ funds would be far better spent on promoting energy efficiency, where no such unequal ‘tradeoffs’ are required.


The club would never have been able to fight the case without the support of Fish Legal, which met all the costs and risks, which could have totalled hundreds of thousands of pounds if the developers had won. This is only possible because of the fighting fund accumulated over decades from the donations and membership subscriptions of tens of thousands of anglers and angling clubs. There is no chance that the club could have stood up to the might of the developers and their expensive lawyers without Fish Legal’s unique legal protection (an appeal, which would increase the legal costs yet further, is still possible).


Coincidentally, Fish Legal (then called the Anglers’ Co-operative Association) was founded back in 1948 shortly before winning a landmark case against pollution for the Pride of Derby Angling Association against British Celanese Ltd in 1952, and then on appeal to the Court of Appeal. PDAA member George Elliott joined the ACA at the time and is still an individual member of Fish Legal and the Angling Trust to this day.


George Elliott said: “Thankfully Fish Legal was able to defend our fishing from this terrible development. I have fished at Sawley weir for decades and have caught barbel, pike, carp, chub, dace, perch and roach from the weirpool. I am so pleased that we will be able to carry on fishing there in the future. It was quite ridiculous to suggest that we should have to fish from metal platforms above the river. Every angler should be a member of the Angling Trust and Fish Legal – together they take action to protect our fish and fishing.”


Andrew Kelton, Fish Legal Solicitor, said[/b[b]]:“I hope that developers will learn from this landmark case that it is vitally important to discuss any proposals at the earliest possible stage with angling clubs who own or lease fishing rights on rivers. If they don’t, they could find themselves in court and having to tear up their expensive plans.”


Mark Lloyd, chief executive of Fish Legal and the Angling Trust said: “We are delighted to have been able to defend one of our member angling clubs in this historic case against an aggressive developer, who was granted an impoundment licence by the so-called Environment Agency to spoil a beautiful river and a prime fishing spot with an ugly, environmentally-damaging turbine purely to turn a profit out of taxpayers’ subsidies. Even a thousand of these schemes would make a negligible contribution to tackling climate change, but each one would have a significant impact on the water environment.”


Keith Fisher, the Vice Chairman of the angling association, having been questioned for three hours in court by the developers' QC, said that:“it was a relief that it was all over and that the bully boy tactics used by the developers had not won through”.


Alan Miller the secretary of the Pride of Derby Angling Association said:"It’s quite a relief that we have won and this special place for fishing is protected for future generations of our members. Some of our members travel considerable distances to fish at this spot. We are truly grateful for all the hard work and dedication that has been put in by the Fish Legal team".
Back to top Go down
http://Rivertac.org
Ed Randall

Ed Randall


Male Posts : 3323
Join date : 2010-11-19
Age : 56
Location : Twickenham

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Nov 21, 2012 5:48 pm

cheers

That reminds me, had my angling trust membership renewal letter through a while back, must try & find it.

This bit looks very bad indeed though:
Quote :
What's more, by granting the licence, the EA handed the company a statutory defence to any claims against it for damage to the fishery caused by modifying water levels and flow rates. Fish Legal therefore had to limit its civil legal action to the narrower point of the impact on the club’s access to the fishery and the physical ability of its members to fish there, but they still won the case.

_________________
TAC Secretary
Angling Trust member #61385
Back to top Go down
Paul Snell




Male Posts : 437
Join date : 2011-06-20
Location : Egham

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Nov 21, 2012 6:45 pm

Brilliant.

Be interesting to see if AT/Fish Legal (can and decide to) now challenge the EA's decision to grant the impoundment licence.

As a matter of interest does anyone the mechanics of challenging the grant of such licences - is it only by way of a judicial review in which case AT/FL may be time-barred in doing so in this case?
Back to top Go down
David Harvey

David Harvey


Male Posts : 5381
Join date : 2010-01-21
Age : 107
Location : Surrey,

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Nov 21, 2012 8:10 pm

Not sure Paul but see if we can find out.

Ed, renew it mate, seems very cheap tonight at £25 a year

bit.ly XCvZIi
Back to top Go down
http://Rivertac.org
Chris Wooding




Posts : 72
Join date : 2011-08-08

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Nov 21, 2012 8:42 pm

Yep 25 quid well spent, especially if it paves the way for schemes closer to home to be blocked.....
Back to top Go down
Ed Randall

Ed Randall


Male Posts : 3323
Join date : 2010-11-19
Age : 56
Location : Twickenham

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyWed Nov 21, 2012 10:28 pm

Didn't need to find the letter, you can do it on-line, all very easy.
Was not due to expire until 9th December but renewed tonight anyway, hopefully they will get a "membership surge" as a result of this success.


_________________
TAC Secretary
Angling Trust member #61385
Back to top Go down
Robin Ottaway




Posts : 32
Join date : 2011-09-02

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Praise the lord   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Nov 22, 2012 10:00 am

Contrary to several recent judgements by the judiciary common sense has at last prevailed so i now beleive in the Lord above.
Back to top Go down
John LeSurf




Male Posts : 348
Join date : 2010-08-16
Age : 69
Location : Hornchurch,Essex

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Nov 22, 2012 12:24 pm

Interesting,Thats why every angler should join AT for the cost of about 6 pints of maggots,but a word of
caution reading the 2nd paragrath of Davids post this was won because the fishing club owned the freehold rights
for this bit of river,this might not apply on the Thames where it is free fishing.
Back to top Go down
David Harvey

David Harvey


Male Posts : 5381
Join date : 2010-01-21
Age : 107
Location : Surrey,

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Nov 22, 2012 12:54 pm

Yes mate it was on the fishing rights but the wording of the overall press release is highly critical of the EA and CRT in licencing in the first place. My feeling is this sends a large shot across the bows of all Hydro developers, the British Hydro assoc etc.

As you say for the cost of a few pints of maggots...

Looks very cheap now
Back to top Go down
http://Rivertac.org
David Harvey

David Harvey


Male Posts : 5381
Join date : 2010-01-21
Age : 107
Location : Surrey,

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Nov 22, 2012 4:08 pm

Back to top Go down
http://Rivertac.org
Robin Ottaway




Posts : 32
Join date : 2011-09-02

Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Wind Turbines   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers EmptyThu Nov 22, 2012 5:55 pm

No suprise that they are rubbish.
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty
PostSubject: Re: Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers   Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers Empty

Back to top Go down
 
Hydropower scheme stopped in landmark legal case by anglers
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» Landmark Case Puts Water Industry ‘In the Dock’
» Special Bailiff Scheme launched to help stamp out fish theft
» Eel Friendly Fisheries Scheme Launched by the NAC
» New Live fish Movement Scheme
» Angling Trust & Fish Legal newsletter July 2015

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum :: Open Section :: News Board :: Angling Trust-
Jump to: