Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum
TAC Members Forum
If you have arrived here and not yet signed up as a member,
please register below using your real name.

Please create a Username that is your First Name and Surname eg. "Joe Bloggs"
(This will ensure quicker activation and save us the need to contact you about changing it)

Our Forum Membership uses Real Names only.
Aliases, Handles, Pseudonyms or any other types of made-up name are not allowed.
This helps to keep it an open and friendly place. Thanks!

www.rivertac.org
Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.


Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum
 
HomeHome  TAC Home PageTAC Home Page  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log in  
Navigation
Search
 
 

Display results as :
 
Rechercher Advanced Search
Latest topics
» Feargal Sharkey accuses Thames Water of sewage 'dumping'
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyFri Sep 04, 2020 4:24 pm by Ed Randall

» COVID-19 - Get Fishing Again
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySun Jun 07, 2020 1:04 pm by Julian Jones

» Eel Trap Molesey - 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyTue May 05, 2020 12:29 pm by Glyn Jones

» GAS STOVES
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyWed Apr 15, 2020 7:13 am by Keith Collett

» Man missing in Thames at Shepperton
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyTue Jan 21, 2020 3:27 pm by Ed Randall

» Semi-Tidal Draw off 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyMon Oct 28, 2019 9:55 pm by Ed Randall

» Citizen Science forum at ZSL ~ 29th October 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Sep 28, 2019 4:19 pm by Ed Randall

» Citizen Crane Forum ~ 16th and 29th October 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Sep 28, 2019 4:16 pm by Ed Randall

» Tidefest match result 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyTue Sep 10, 2019 8:50 am by Ed Randall

» Closed season retained following public consultation
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu Aug 22, 2019 12:20 pm by Ed Randall

» Houseboat destroyed by fire in Hampton
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyMon Aug 12, 2019 9:30 am by Ed Randall

» Local tackle shops
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyFri Jul 05, 2019 1:16 pm by Trevor Rowe

» New Season, New Licence...
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyFri Jun 14, 2019 12:24 am by Julian Jones

» FORCE Clean-Up in Donkey Wood ~ Sun 14th April 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySun Apr 21, 2019 8:19 am by Ed Randall

» The Big one - Farnborough 23rd-24th March 2019
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySun Feb 10, 2019 11:30 am by Keith Collett

» Thames So Full Of Cocaine It’s Pranging Out London’s Eels
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyTue Jan 22, 2019 9:27 am by Trevor Rowe

» "Citizen Crane" project - sampling dates
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu Jan 10, 2019 8:51 am by Ed Randall

» New Members: Real Names please
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu Jan 10, 2019 8:36 am by Ed Randall

» Semi-Tidal draw-off 2018
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Oct 27, 2018 5:44 pm by Ed Randall

» Thames Water Blitz - 19th/20th October 2018
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyTue Oct 02, 2018 7:21 pm by Ed Randall

» Citizen Crane Forum ~ 26th October 2018
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 7:41 pm by Ed Randall

» Invitation to the 2018 Eel forum ~ 15th October
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 7:38 pm by Ed Randall

» Mystery of dead eels found in rivers
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 6:43 pm by Ed Randall

» Eel Trap Clean Up/ training 5th May 2018 10am
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySat Aug 25, 2018 6:40 pm by Ed Randall

» A new address for 2017 ~ forum.rivertac.org
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptySun Aug 19, 2018 12:48 pm by Admin

» Hampton Riviera removed
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu Aug 16, 2018 10:41 pm by Ed Randall

» Roads closed everywhere ~ July 29th/30th ~ bike race
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyMon Aug 06, 2018 10:14 am by John LeSurf

» *Thames Tunnel (Tideway Tunnel)*
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyWed Jul 18, 2018 9:56 am by John LeSurf

» new hotel at hampton court means loss of fishing
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyWed Jul 04, 2018 1:26 pm by Ed Randall

» FORCE clean-up in Donkey Wood ~ Sun 13th May 2018
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu May 17, 2018 10:16 am by JeffHowe

Angling Data View
River Levels
UK Map

Thames Tides

 

 Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat

Go down 
2 posters
AuthorMessage
David Harvey

David Harvey


Male Posts : 5381
Join date : 2010-01-21
Age : 107
Location : Surrey,

Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat Empty
PostSubject: Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat   Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu May 17, 2012 12:00 pm

The Angling Trust has weighed into the debate on new plans for a privately funded concrete barrage across the environmentally sensitive Severn Estuary and challenged former Welsh Secretary Peter Hain's claims that fish and birdlife would not be damaged by the turbines and changes to habitat.

Giant construction consortium Halcrow are behind new plans by Corlan Hafren to build a massive barrage across the Severn estuary from Brean Down to Lavernac Point in South Wales and are presently in discussion with DECC to win govt approval for the scheme. Over the years there have been many proposals for power generation from the Severn estuary, mostly by means of a barrage, all rejected after scrutiny on environmental and economic grounds. As recently as 2010 a two year feasibility study felt unable to justify government backing for the scheme.

Then in November last year Corlan Hafren announced new plans for a barrage. Although technically different in some regards from the scheme for which the govt could see "no strategic case for investment" in 2010, the recent proposals have much in common with the original in as much as they still pose a significant threat to the already fragile populations of migratory fish and bird species that use the estuary.

Peter Hain, the M.P. for Neath in South Wales and a long time backer of power from the Severn has added his weight to the campaign for a barrage by resigning his shadow cabinet post in order to devote his time to promotion of the scheme. He claims that "one by one all the environmental objections have been overcome" and that "turbine design has been reconfigured to make sure it is fish friendly". Hain has also claimed that the RSPB are warming to the scheme, something that has been strongly disputed by their Conservation Director Martin Harper.

Angling Trust CEO Mark Lloyd said:
"Peter Hain needs to explain how these fish mincing turbines would not damage the salmon, seatrout and shad that run the Severn Estuary and into the Wye, Usk and Severn tributaries and a myriad of sea fish that spawn in the estuary. Until the plans are revealed and examined in detail it is difficult to see how the structure could ever be described as fish friendly when it has an array of a thousand turbines (800 more than in the 2010 STPG plans) which will work on both phases of the tide ie. doubling their running time to twenty hours a day. These rivers host 25% of the total salmonoid fish runs in England and Wales and enjoy legal protection via the European Habitats Directive which cannot simply be wished away by Peter Hain or any other politician. We are seeking a meeting with Mr Hain and his successor Owen Smith MP to make them aware of anglers concerns."

The new design being submitted by the group is still a low head barrage but will only hold back three to four metres of water as opposed to the seven metre head that the old STPG barrage planned. Designers claim this will lower the pressure in the turbines and lessen the risk of fish kill through blade strike as they will rotate at lower speeds. All this of course is purely theoretical and even if true only represents part of the threat to fish trying to navigate their way up or downstream through the barrage. Mystery still shrouds the exact behaviours of migrating fish and a barrier across the channel will undoubtedly alter the very nature of the estuary and its delicate relationship with the fish that use it. Flow patterns and water temperatures will change, sedimentation and scouring will occur and nobody knows how this will alter the cues that trigger movement in the affected species.

The threat to the Severn estuary and its unique environment seems to be very real and ever present. The massive potential for clean carbon neutral power production holds huge attraction for developers who have seen the price of energy skyrocket to the point where the most unlikely and previously prohibitive schemes have become viable. At the same time governments tied to emission reduction agreements are realising that wind power alone cannot solve their dilemma and that nuclear power is now extremely short of backers.

The push for power production from the Severn has never been stronger and with it comes the very real threat of local extinction for the migratory fish species that use the channel as a conduit to their spawning grounds. In the case of the Atlantic Salmon this represents some 24% of the breeding population. This could be the sacrifice being contemplated in the quest for carbon neutral power.

In a statement Martin Harper, the RSPB's conservation director said:
"A two-year study by Decc concluded that the strategic case for government support of a £30 billion barrage had not been made. The 2010 statement confirmed that the government would not return to this unless or until the strategic case changed and not within the life of this Parliament.

We welcome the opportunity for constructive dialogue with both Peter Hain and with potential developers, and we welcome the up-front consideration being given to reducing or avoiding the environmental impacts of a barrage scheme.

However, we do not recognise Peter Hain's interpretation of our position. The RSPB has been clear, and the Decc study confirmed, that a conventional, high-head barrage would effectively destroy the estuary, and that the scale of the effects of a lower-head barrage on the estuary, on birds, fish, and flood risk are still unclear and would need to be carefully assessed.

We don't believe that a post-barrage estuary would support greater wildlife or potential for bird life than it does at present, and to date no details of the turbine design have been made available, preventing us from having a view on the likely impacts on fish.

Until details of the resulting proposal are made available, it is wrong to suggest that environmental objections have been overcome."

Gareth Clubb, director of Friends of the Earth (Wales) said:
"We have yet to see the specific proposals for a Severn barrage that Peter Hain is campaigning for, but we have real concerns about the potential impact of a massive concrete structure on an internationally important wildlife habitat.

We agree that we need to invest in clean British energy, including tidal power, to reduce our nation's dependence on dirty and expensive fossil fuels, create jobs and tackle climate change.

But there are alternative ways to capture tidal energy that could cause less damage - and could also provide clean energy sooner than the 20 years it will take to build a barrage."
Back to top Go down
http://Rivertac.org
Ed Randall

Ed Randall


Male Posts : 3323
Join date : 2010-11-19
Age : 56
Location : Twickenham

Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat Empty
PostSubject: Re: Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat   Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat EmptyThu May 17, 2012 3:32 pm

The knock-on effects of these things are almost impossible to predict... I was watching something on TV about Yellowstone Park the other week. After the re-introduction of wolves (which had been labelled as "bad" wildlife) it was found that certain types of trees (Aspen etc.) began to thrive again. No not some magic ingredient in wolf poo, but the subsequent reduction in populations of wolf prey which had destroyed those trees.

_________________
TAC Secretary
Angling Trust member #61385
Back to top Go down
 
Angling Trust warns of new Severn Barrage Threat
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» Angling Groups meet MP to discuss fears over Severn barrage
» Proposed Barrage across the Severn Estuary 'could be absolutely devastating'
» Angling Trust newsletter
» Angling Trust Strengthens Team to Focus on National Angling Strategy


» Angling Trust moves to secure Cemex waters for angling

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Thames Anglers' Conservancy Members Forum :: Open Section :: News Board :: Angling Trust-
Jump to: